The Five Levels of Listening

A Strategic Edge for Modern Leaders

Great leaders don’t just talk, they listen. Yet listening is not a single skill, it is a progression.

Neuroscience shows that deep listening activates the brain’s anterior insula (empathy) and prefrontal cortex (decision-making), allowing us to interpret both words and the emotions behind them. Psychologist

Carl Rogers called this “active listening,’ but today’s workplaces, shaped by hybrid schedules, digital distractions and uneven DEI support, demand something more deliberate and continuous.

Why It Matters Now

The modern leader faces a workplace unlike any before. Hybrid and remote teams stretched across time zones, multigenerational staff expecting inclusion and information overload that rewards speed yet punishes shallow attention.

Research backs the urgency. McKinsey finds that companies with inclusive-leadership practices are 35 % more likely to outperform peers, while Gallup reports employees who feel heard are 4.6 times more engaged. Listening is no longer a soft skill, it is a competitive advantage.

From Insight to Practice

To translate this science into everyday leadership, we need a clear map of how listening actually unfolds.

Leaders do not leap from silence to perfect empathy,  they move through distinct stages, each with its own risks and rewards.

Understanding these stages and recognising where you are in real time, turns “being a good listener’ from a vague aspiration into a repeatable discipline. Below are the five levels of listening every leader can master to inspire trust, sharpen strategy and create lasting cultural change.

1. Ignoring: The Cost of Disconnection

Every conversation begins with a choice, presence or distraction.

When leaders skim emails or mentally draft their next response, they enter what University of Michigan researchers called ’empathic depletion’, cutting comprehension and empathy by up to 40 percent.

That single lapse today can echo tomorrow. When women or BAME professionals already feel overlooked, even a brief signal of disinterest reinforces the belief that their input is optional. Trust frays, innovation slows and the next meeting starts with silent scepticism.

2. Pretending: The Courtesy Listen

Polite nods without true engagement may look efficient, but people sense the gap instantly. Gallup data shows employees who feel unheard are nearly five times more likely to disengage or leave within a year.

For leaders pursuing DEI goals without strong HR backing, this is more than a courtesy failure, it is a credibility crisis. Once a team doubts your attention, future explanations or course-corrections land hollow, no matter how well-worded.

3. Selective Listening: Confirmation Over Curiosity

Selective listening surfaces when leaders hear only what supports their existing narrative.

Stanford studies on confirmation bias show it narrows creativity by roughly 30 percent, a slow bleed on innovation that compounds quarter after quarter. In multicultural teams this becomes critical.

A quiet comment about unequal promotion paths, ignored in the moment, may later emerge as a formal grievance or lost talent. Cause and effect are real here, the opportunity to address bias exists only when it is first voiced.

4. Attentive Listening: Understanding the Message

Attentive listening requires total presence, tracking words, tone and body language and then reflecting them back to confirm understanding.

Google’s Project Aristotle found that teams with leaders who listen at this level outperform others in problem-solving and retention because they feel genuine psychological safety.

It is safe to say that leaders who practice this consistently can connect the dots across weeks or projects, noticing patterns, caregiving stress, religious observances, subtle microaggressions, that no policy manual anticipates but that shape performance and morale.

5. Empathic Listening: Hearing What’s Unsaid

At the highest level, leaders tune in to feelings and subtext, catching the story behind the story.

Harvard research on the social neural network shows empathic listening strengthens trust circuits in the brain, creating loyalty that withstands stress and change. This is where continuity matters most.

When HR procedures lag, an empathic leader notices quiet disengagement or early burnout before it erupts into turnover or conflict, preserving both the individual and the organisation’s collective memory.

Integrating the Inner Stages of Listening

These five levels of listening are more than a checklist, they trace an ‘inner journey’ that every leader must walk again and again.

Early in a conversation, it is easy to slip into \waiting to talk\, a subtle form of ignoring or pretending.

The challenge is noticing that impulse and pulling yourself back to presence. The next step, ‘hearing the words’, demands that you quiet the mental commentary and take in the literal message before leaping to conclusions. Only then can you move toward ‘understanding the message’, which requires curiosity about context, culture and unspoken constraints.

The highest stage, ‘recognising emotions’ and ‘hearing what is unsaid’, calls for humility and courage. The willingness to sense a team member’s hesitation or pain, even when it is uncomfortable to acknowledge.

Seasoned leaders know this is not a one-time climb but a discipline.

Practical strategies help. Schedule “no-tech’ one-on-ones, keep a quick reflection journal after tough meetings and summarise what you heard in real time to confirm understanding.

These habits train the brain’s prefrontal cortex to stay focused and strengthen the social neural network that supports empathy. Over weeks and months, you will notice quieter rooms opening up, people share ideas earlier, conflicts surface sooner and solutions arrive faster.

Let us go back to the leaders guiding hybrid teams, managing cultural differences and operating without full HR or DEI support, strategic listening is no longer optional, it is the core of modern leadership.

A manager who merely “hears the update’ risks missing the tension between remote and on-site staff, or the silent fatigue of employees balancing caregiving and deadlines. By practicing deep, empathic listening, you intercept these signals before they harden into turnover, disengagement, or costly conflict.

It is important to consider the ripple effects. Psychological safety rises, innovation accelerates and decision-making improves because more perspectives are voiced early.Research from Google’s Project Aristotle links this environment directly to higher team performance, while a McKinsey study shows inclusive leaders drive 35 % greater financial returns.

A strategic listening strategy for leaders means designing for these outcomes:

• Structure time for dialogue: Regular listening sessions or “office hours’ where agenda belongs to the team.

• Model vulnerability: Share your own uncertainties to invite honesty.

• Close the loop: Act visibly on what you’ve heard so trust compounds.

When you practice this level of listening consistently, you answer the unspoken questions:

• Do you value me?

• Do you see the pattern?

• Will you act on what you hear? before they even surface.

You have to admit, the result is not only a more cohesive team but a resilient organisation where trust becomes a renewable asset and strategy moves at the speed of genuine understanding.

---

If this perspective on strategic listening resonates with you, add your voice to the dialogue.

Like this post to signal that listening matters, share it with a colleague or team to spark a deeper conversation and leave a comment with your own experience of moving from hearing words to truly understanding what’s unsaid.

Your story could be the catalyst that helps another leader begin their own journey toward transformational listening.